Robert May - President of the Royal Society, March 2002
“While I do not see GM crops and foods as posing dangers to human health or to the creation of invasive ‘superweeds’ that are significantly different from those associated with any ‘conventionally produced’ new crops and foods, I do worry about applications of this new technology which can lead to yet further intensification of agriculture, with adverse consequences for biological diversity. I worry about an ever more ‘Silent Spring’, as populations of birds and other animals continue their documented patterns of decrease.
More positively, I see the new GM methods, if used appropriately, as helping us work towards a doubly Green Revolution, in which we grow our food more productively and efficiently, while at the same time shaping agriculture to its environment rather than wrenching the environment to the agriculture with unsustainable fossil-fuel energy subsidies. I believe our emphasis should be on using the new technologies to produce crops that are drought tolerant, salt tolerant, resistant to particular insects (thus avoiding the need for external application of insecticides which kill both target and non-target organisms), and – in more visionary terms – engineering in nutrients to remedy deficiencies in the diets of local populations, or even mechanisms for non-leguminous plants to produce their own nitrogenous fertilisers.
Compared with fossil derived fuels, bio-ethanol generally has lower emissions, saves energy and improves air quality and hence public health.


